& Hotels

Cottages & Rentals

For an authentic & cozy vacation experience

Newland's Resort

11262 Township Road 266, Lakeview, Ohio 43331

This Season, relax in a comfortable cottage at Newland’s Resort and enjoy beautiful Indian Lake under the shade of a mature tree or on the warm sunlit grounds! Enjoy the beauty of Indian Lake in one of three quaint cottages. Each cottage features 2 bedrooms, a spacious living area, air conditioning, a boat dock/ramp, and direct TV. Take in the waterfront views in cottages 1 & 2 or unwind upon a hill and overlook the lake in cottage 3.

Marble Surface

Blue Jacket Cabin

Bring the whole family to this beautiful cabin with a view of Indian Lake. This 4 bedroom cabin sleeps 16 and features wifi, satallite TV, A/C, washer & dryer, fireplace, pool, spacious deck, playground, pond, and outdoor grill. 
10601 State Route 235 N
Lakeview, OH 43331

Logan-Tarhe Cottage

Enjoy views of the lake as you and your friends & family stay in this 5 bedroom cottage. This rental comfortably sleeps 16 people, has A/C, wifi, washer & dryer, fireplace, satellite TV, spacious deck, pool, and playground.
10601 State Route 235 N
Lakeview, OH 43331

Oak Island Retreat

Sitting amongst the beautiful, mature trees that shade this 1/3-acre island, lies a quaint 3-bedroom cottage filled with everything you need for the perfect peaceful getaway. Enjoy having the entire island to yourself while enjoying the gorgeous 360-degree views of Indian Lake.
Oak Island
Lakeview, OH 43331

Frontier Cottages

Choose between 5 newly-renovated cottages situated directly across from Indian Lake. Each cottage offers a cozy vacation experience, located right between Russells Point and Lakeview so you can experience a little bit of everything and then return to a relaxing and comfortable cottage to end the night
10991 State Route 366
Lakeview, OH 43331

Virgil's Lakefront Cottage

Located on one the most beautiful islands of Indian Lake, this property is a perfect vacation spot for those wanting to relax and enjoy a week or two away from the everyday. This lakefront home is perfectly situated on the northwest corner of Seminole Island, providing an excellent open water view of the lake. 
10663 Seminole Shore Drive
Lakeview, OH 43331

Bradshaw's House of Oars

Enjoy your stay in this cute 2 bedroom, 1 bathroom cottage in Chippewa Park. This cottage is located close to the state boat docks and sleeps 6. The master bedroom houses a queen sized bed and the second bedroom contains full sized bunk beds. 
11208 Big Bear Path
Lakeview, OH 43331

Captain's View Lakefront

Spend your time away in this 2 bedroom, 2 bath rental property with beautiful, open panoramic, and unobstructed view of Indian Lake. This rental can comfortably sleep 6-8 people and comes completely furnished.
All you need to do is book your stay, and the rest is taken care of!

10783 State Route 366
Lakeview, OH 43331

Cranetown Waterfront

Enjoy beautiful Indian Lake from our cottage on Cranetown Island. The kitchen with breakfast bar opens into the living room with two sofas. There are 3 bedrooms (2 queens/1 full) and bathroom with full size tiled shower. A three seasons back porch faces the water. The cottage was totally renovated in 2013.

10171 Pleasantview Drive
Huntsville, OH 43324

Froggy's Lake Resort

Froggy's offers 5 units for rent, nightly or weekly. Each unit comfortably sleeps six adults. Boat docks are available for overnight if you have a rented unit. Call today for unit availability and more information.

11065 Township Road 293
Lakeview, OH 43331

indian lake waterfront rentals & Sage cottage

Lakefront rentals on Turkeyfoot offer calming lake views w/spectacular sunsets. Includes picnic table, gas grill, fire pit, shaded backyard & private boat dock just a few steps from your front door. Walking distance from 3 "hot spots" of entertainment; Acheson's Resort, Froggy's & Tilton Hilton. 

10795 CR 293
Lakeview, OH 43331

Lilypad Cottage

This funky waterfront "Lilypad" cottage sits right on the water of the quiet peninsula of Sassafras Point at Indian Lake. 2 Bedrooms that sleeps 5. All Appliances and utensils, gas grill and dining area on the outdoor deck are for renter's use. Relax by the side-yard firepit, and enjoy your stay!

11083 Sassafras Drive
Lakeview, OH 43331

Treehouse Cottage

This adorable waterfront "Tree House" cottage is nestled into the hillside of the quiet peninsula of Sassafras Point at Indian Lake, OH. Enjoy the gas grill and dining area on the outdoor deck below, watch the water just a few steps away and relax by the stone fire ring in the backyard.

11083 Sassafras Drive
Lakeview, OH 43331

Indian Lake Vacation Rentals

Stay at the beautiful 2 bedroom, 2 bath, waterfront hideaway cottage that is nestled away on aquiet peninsula at Indian Lake that has a great deal to offer and can accommodate up to 6.  This rental includes a boat dock directly in front of the cottage.

11172 Newland Drive
Lakeview, OH 43331

Islandview Cottages

This quaint cottage has 2 bedrooms and 1 bathroom. The kitchen is fully equipped and internet is provided. Outside, enjoy family time and take advantage of the fire ring and outdoor grill, both gas & charcoal. Located within stumbling distance of The Moose and The Eagles, a guaranteed good time.

14223 Collingwood Drive
Lakeview, OH 43331

Paradise View Cottages

Stay in one of two vacation homes at Indian Lake with amazing views of the lake. One house sleeps up to six. And one sleeps up to 14. Just bring food, clothes & a boat!

406 Maple Street
Russells Point, OH 43348

Orchard Island Get Away

Family Friendly!  Spacious 2 bedroom (Sleeps 5/6) with 1.5 baths.
Indoor/Outdoor Dining, bar
with pool table, large yard and patio with a
fire pit. Gravel lane for easy boat &
trailer parking. Walking distance to Fox Island and Spend A Day Marina. 

8870 College
Lakeview, OH 43331

The North Cottage

Enjoy a relaxing vacation in a charming cottage on Orchard Island at Indian Lake, Ohio.  Experience on-the-water living and the luxury of your own private built-in swimming pool. Indulge in beautiful sunsets and star gazing from the lakeside patio and wake up to a lakeside view from the living room.

9525 Cottage Grove Ave
Lakeview, OH 43331

Home of the brave

Beautiful, newly remodeled 3 bedroom (Sleeps 7) with new kitchen appliances! Huge yard with plenty of parking on a quiet street. Firepit, croquet, corn hole, grill and a game room with foosball table, darts and board games provided. Just around the corner from Indian Lake's Northside hotspots. No pets please. 

11194 Cherokee Path
Lakeview, OH 43331

Remodeled waterfront Lake house

Completely renovated from top to bottom, fully equipped & right on the water. Wide open floorplan with breathtaking views of Indian Lake from the real wall of windows. Backyard includes private dock, porch, patio  firepit and grill. Modern amenities include high-speed, reliable wi-fi, 4K HDR TV with YouTube (live) TV and built in USB outlets throughout for charging your devices.

Russells Point, Ohio 43348

Waddle Inn

This cozy lake cottage on Tecumseh Island is a luxury getaway, just steps from the water! Enjoy the perfect location, close to everything, surrounding lake views, stylishly remodeled interior, gas burning fireplace, fully furnished kitchen, television, and high speed internet. This cottage has two bedrooms and sleeps up to 7 guests. 

10644 Buckeye Drive
Huntsville, OH 43324

Breezy Way Getaway

Relax like nowhere else on Indian Lake as you enjoy the quaint surroundings and the benefit of being on open water. Our 2-bed, 1.5 bath cottage features all the modern amenities with ample parking and dock for your watercraft or fishing. Enjoy your days relaxing in the hammock, taking a spin on our kayaks, or float off the dock.

9183 Breezy Way Drive
Belle Center, Ohio 43310

Within walking distance of Froggy's and across the street from Tilton Hilton, "Serenity Now!". 2 bedrooms/1 bath, plus sleeper sofa & air mattress comfortably accommodates 5-6 people. Also includes: shaded backyard deck w/gas grill & fire pit, air conditioning, satellite tv, fully equipped kitchen,washer & dryer, and bath, bed & kitchen linens.

< - >
10826 Turkeyfoot Rd.
Lakeview, OH 43331

Serenity Now!

Anchor Bend Bungalow

Enjoy the cabin feel of this totally remodeled Lake house complete with modern amenities and Lake views from the open concept kitchen, dining room, living room & large deck. Relax, sunbathe or fish from the waterfront deck. Comfortably sleeps 8 and is well equipped with a fully stocked kitchen, air conditioning , gas grill flatscreen, fire pit & dock.

Park St (Turkeyfoot)
Lakeview, OH 43331

Do you own a rental property at Indian Lake?

We want your home, cottage, or cabin featured here for FREE!

to tell us all about your property!

Area Hotels

Just in case you're looking for something more familiar

The Comfort Inn

260 Northview Drive
Bellefontaine, OH 43311

Super 8

1117 N Main Street
Bellefontaine, OH 43311